Welcome to Angelica’s Ice Cream, Sweets & Treats

Angelica’s Ice Cream, Sweets & Treats is located at Shoreham Plaza, 99 Route 25A in Shoreham, NY.  We are the North Fork Long Island’s favorite destination for premium Hershey’s ice cream and handcrafted sweets.

We serve up 50 flavors of award-winning Hershey’s Premium Ice Cream, from classic Old Fashioned Vanilla and Butter Pecan to indulgent originals like Dark Chocolate Raspberry Truffle, Salty Caramel Truffle, and Brookie Dough Blast.

Whether you’re craving a hand-scooped cone, an acai bowl, a refreshing Italian Ice, or a showstopping custom ice cream cake, Angelica’s has something sweet for everyone — including kids’ flavors, reduced-fat/no-sugar-added options, and the OATMAZING oat milk line.

Beyond the scoop, we offer gourmet chocolates & truffles, candy bouquets, and gift baskets perfect for birthdays, holidays, and every reason in between. Check our seasonal specials for limited-time treats you won’t want to miss.

Real Ingredients. Real Ice Cream. Real Smiles.

99 Route 25A, Shoreham, NY 11786 · 631.647.5455